Ancilla Iuris

Lagen des Rechts
Constellations of Law

Ancilla
Iuris

Equity or Dworkin’s Egalitarianism

Principles that Incorporate Policies Versus Principles that Stand on Their Own

Ancilla Iuris 2016
Article

Download PDF

Ronald Dworkin contended that the process of judicial interpretation in the United States and the United Kingdom is and should be regulated by egalitarian principles that are partially constitutive of the law. In contrast, I develop the rudiments of a theory of judicial activity that maintains the autonomy of principles, while recognizing that their very meaning is dependent on the consequences of their implementation. To make my argument manageable within the context of this paper, I contrast Dworkin’s notion of equality, which is essentially procedural, with an image of equity that merges formal and substantive claims, recognizes that the implementation of egalitarian norms may accentuate inequality, and mandates actions to enhance substantively egalitarian outcomes.

Mark Gould, Equity or Dworkin’s Egalitarianism – Principles that Incorporate Policies Versus Principles that Stand on Their Own, in: Ancilla Iuris (anci.ch) 2016, 61-85.

The text is subject to a non-commercial, no derivative works Creative Commons license (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).